This is an outdated version published on 16-09-2026. Read the most recent version.

Authors

  • Dilorom MUMINJONOVA INTERNATIONAL ISLAMIC ACADEMY OF UZBEKISTAN Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.47980/TLOI/2023/3/%25p

Keywords:

Israiliyyats Bani Israil acceptable narratives Abdullah ibn Salam Kaab al-Axbar Vahb ibn Munabbih Tora Zabur Gospel Qur’an

Abstract

Religious studies is one of the subjects of the humanitarian education area that involves the cultural, educational, and intellectual history of mankind. The field of comparative theology, which is considered a major branch of the science of religion, was studied separately not only in the West, but also in the Middle Ages in the East, and the first founders of this science came from the East. One of the factors in the comparative study of religions in Eastern Muslim society is the separation of real and false narratives. There are two different views on this matter. According to the first view, it is to prove that Islam is the true religion, and according to the second view, the sources of Judaism and Christianity have been studied in order to verify the reliability of the Islamic religion, in particular, Israelliyat (narratives) that included in the interpretations of the Qur’an and hadiths. For these reasons, Muslim scholars addressed Israelliyat in their works.

This article examines the reasons for the introduction of the Israiliyyat narrations based on Jewish and Christian sources in order to interpret the Qur’anic interpretations and hadiths more broadly. The comprehensive study and analysis of the narratives recorded in the Qur’an was the main reason behind the inclusion of narratives of Israiliyyat in the islamic sources. During the period of the Companions, the narratives of Israiliyyat came as a consequence of asking and learning from Jews and Christians living in Madinah or from Muslims who accepted the religion of Islam and were aware of their religion’s sacred sources in order to understand the stories entioned in the Qur’an. By the time of the Tabeins, the tafsirs, which consisted of stories narrated by all Israelite narrators, had lost their reliability as a result of the use of unreliable reports and stories. Even so, since the basis and roots of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam are the same, narratives of Israiliyyat play an essential role in the comparative analysis of the sacred sources of these religions. Muslim scholars divided Israiliyyat narratives into three distinct groups:

  1. Acceptable narratives, the truthfulness of which are unable to be doubted. Their authenticity is confirmed by the hadiths of the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh), for example, the person in the story of the Prophet Moses and the righteous man in the Qur’an is the Prophet Khizr, narrated by Imam Bukhari.
  2. The narratives that are neither accepted nor rejected. It is unsure if they are true or false. These types of stories are narrated for advice and instruction.
  3. False narratives that contradict the Qur’an. Such narrations are not verified as they contradict the Islamic theology. The narrative of the crucifixion of Jesus is an example of this.

The article also discusses the narratives of Israiliyyat and the narrators who told them, which are frequently used in Qur’anic interpretations. Several Israilliyat are researched

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Similar Articles

Sohibjon UMMATALIYEV, EARLY MEDIEVAL  SOURCES  ON ISLAMIC HISTORY AND THEIR TITLES , The Light of Islam: Vol. 8 No. 3 (2025)

Otabek MAKHMUDOV, ANALYSIS OF LATIN TRANSLATIONS OF ISLAMIC TEXTS WRITTEN IN MEDIEVAL ARABIST CENTERS (Based on 12th–13th Century Manuscripts) , The Light of Islam: Vol. 8 No. 3 (2025)

Lazizaxon Abbasovna ALIDJANOVA, Lazzat Kasymbekovna RYSBEKOVA, HUMAN HEALTH IN THE DOCTRINE OF ISLAM AND THE EVOLUTION OF HOSPITALS IN MUSLIM COUNTRIES , The Light of Islam: Vol. 7 No. 1 (2024)

Prof. , IBN SINA AND HIS PHILOSOPHY OF INTERPRETING QURANIC SURAHS , The Light of Islam: Vol. 9 No. 3 (2026)

Ahrorxon ABDURASHIDOV, THE QUR’AN IN ABU HAFS AL-NASAFI’S TAFSIR AND ITS IMPACT ON HUMAN MORAL DEVELOPMENT AND SOCIAL STABILITY , The Light of Islam: Vol. 9 No. 3 (2026)

Sirojiddin SHODMONOV, AN  ANALYSIS  OF  SCHOLARLY PERSPECTIVES  ON  THE  CONDITIONS  OF TAWĀTUR  IN  THE  QIRĀʾĀT , The Light of Islam: Vol. 8 No. 4 (2025)

Ramzjon Raximdjanovich ISAKDJANOV, GNOSEOLOGICAL PRINCIPLES OF IBN SINA IN THE FIELD OF ISLAMIC PHILOSOPHY , The Light of Islam: Vol. 6 No. 1 (2023)

Muborakxon IBROHIMOVA, METHODOLOGICAL APPROACHES  OF MUSLIM  SCHOLARS TO THE  STUDY  OF RELIGIONS , The Light of Islam: Vol. 9 No. 1 (2026)

Ramzjon Raximdjanovich ISAKDJANOV, IBN SINA’S EXOTERICISM IN METAPHYSICS AND THE INTERPRETATION OF THE WORLD , The Light of Islam: Vol. 9 No. 2 (2026)

Mumin Mirzo Murodjon ugli ABDUPATTAYEV, Bibigulnar Amalbaevna ERBOSYNOVA , REFLECTION OF BELIEFS OF JUDAISM IN MEDIEVAL HISTORY OF RELIGIOUS SOURCES , The Light of Islam: Vol. 7 No. 1 (2024)

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.