DOI:
https://doi.org/10.47980/TLOI/2023/3/12%20-%2020Keywords:
illat maqasid shariat usul al-fiqh furu’ al- fiqh secret wisdom jurisprudence of prayers and transactionsAbstract
In this article, the important books of two medieval scholars of Mawerannahr – al-Hakim at-Tirmidhi and al-Qaffal ash-Shashi on «maqasid ash-sharia» – «objectives of Sharia» are analyzed. Maqasid al-Sharia – explains the wisdom, goals, ideas, and reasons behind the rulings of Islam. The transformation of «Maqasid ash-Sharia» into the first systematic doctrine, the creation of its theoretical foundations corresponded to the 9th-10th centuries.
The article analyzes al-Hakim at-Tirmidhi’s activity as the first maqasidi scholar. The works written by several scholars who lived in the period and region close to at-Tirmidhi and who shared maqasidi ideas were reviewed in general, and the work «Mahasin ash-sharia» by another great scholar al-Qaffal ash-Shashi from Mawerannahr was selected for comparison due to the following factors: firstly, the proximity of the region and time, the popularity of ash-Shashi’s work, and that it has come down to our time in its entirety. The article highlights that al-Qaffal ash-Shashi was representative of the Shafi’i madhab in Mawerannahr, and al-Hakim at-Tirmidhi, although considered as Hanafi madhab follower, was mentioned in the famous work «Tabaqat ash-Shafiiyya al-Kubra» among the second rank of Shafi’i madhab scholars.
In the article, the theme of «cause or purpose of rulings» is emphasized in at-Tirmidhi’s «Ithbat al-ilal» and ash-Shashi’s «Mahasin ash-sharia». The method used by both scholars in determining the causes of judgments is discussed, and it is revealed in the article that in at-Tirmidhi’s approach mystical mentality is the priority, while ash-Shashi relied on real reality within the framework of rational thinking.
At-Tirmidhi and ash-Shashi discussed a number of similar topics in their works, but in most cases came to different conclusions. It is shown in the article that the similar conclusions reached in determining some causes of certain jurisprudential rulings are explained by the limitation of the possibility of mystic interpretation of the subject.
In the conclusion of the article, author came to conclusion that, at-Tirmidhi and ash-Shashi looked at in harmony to the causes in jurisprudence of prayers and transactions, and detected the differences in their styles, and peculiarities of the lexical-analytical, experience, agreement, philosophical, and practical methods used by at-Tirmidhi in «Ithbat al-ilal» were analyzed. It is revealed that the five methods listed above reflect the scope of al-Hakim at-Tirmidhi’s approach in «Ithbat al-ilal».
Downloads
References
1. Ash-Shоshi, Abu Bakr Qaffоl (2007). Mahasin ash-Sharia / Muhammad Ali Samak tahqiqi. Bayrut: Dor al-kutub al-ilmiyya (in Arabic).
2. At-Termiziy, Muhammad al-Hakim (2008). Navodir al-usul. V.I. Qohira: Maktaba Imom al-Buxoriy (in Arabic).
3. At-Termiziy, Muhammad al-Hakim (1965). As-sola va maqosiduho. Qohira: Dor al-kitab al-arabiy.(in Arabic).
4. At-Termiziy, Muhammad al-Hakim (1981). Ilm al-avliyo / Somi Nasr nashri. Qohira: al-Maktaba al-hurriya al-hadisa (in Arabic).
5. At-Termiziy, Muhammad al-Hakim (1998). Isbot al-ilal. Kasablanka: an-Najah al-jadida (in Arabic).
6. At-Termiziy, Muhammad al-Hakim (2005). Al-Furuq va manʼ at-taroduf. Ajuza: Maktaba al-Iman (in Arabic).
7. Adnon, Usoma., Rabobia, Basma Ali (2015). “Aloqa maqosid ash-sharia bi-l-illa va-l-munasaba va-l-hikma: dirosa taʼsiliyya fiqhiyya”. Dirosot ulum ash-sharia va-l-qonun. Iordaniya universiteti nashri.Vol. 2015. Iss. 3. Article 42 (in Arabic).
8. Auda, Jasser (2008). Maqasid Al-Shariah: A Beginner’s Guide. London, Vashington: The international Institute of Islamic Thought (in English).
9. Auda, Jasser (2008). Maqasid Al-Shariah as Philosophy of Islamic Law: A Systems Approach. London, Vashington: The international Institute of Islamic Thought (in English).
10. Azamatov, R. (2018).Teoriya tseley shariata i yeyo svyaz s istochnikami islamskogo prava. Ufa: Izd-vo BGPU (in Russian).
11. Baraka, A. (2014). Al-Hakim at-Termiziy va nazariyyatuhu fi-l-vilaya. Qohira: Maktaba Vahba (in Arabic).
12. Мухамедов, Н. А. (2014). Хазрат Имам Абу Бакр Каффал Шаши – мухаддис из Ташкента. Peoples of eurasia. history, culture and interaction problems, 130. http://www.sociosphera.com/files/conference/2014/k-04_05_14.pdf#page=130
13. Muhamedov N. (2015). Keffal Şaşî’nin Diplomatik Faaliyeti. Marmara Türkiyat Araştırmaları Dergisi 2 (2), 119-126. https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/282071.
14. Faxriddinov, Zafar (2019). “Hakim Termiziyning Markaziy Osiyo ilmiy-maʼnaviy muhitidagi o‘rni hamda tafsir va lug‘at ilmiga qo‘shgan hissasi”. The Light of Islam. Vol. 2019. Iss. 4. Article 9 (in Uzbek).
15. Gafurova, I. M. (2020). The Samanids mausoleum as a monument of dynastic architecture of the early middle ages. ISJ Theoretical & Applied Science, 01 (81), 329-334.
16. G‘urob, Ahmad Abdulhamid (1988). Abulhasan Omiriyning “Kitab al-iʼlam bi manaqib al-islam” asari kirish qismi. Ar-Riyod: Dor al-asola (in Arabic).
17. Haydar, Jabbor Daftar (2019). “Dalolat al-asl al-lug‘aviy inda al-Hakim at-Termiziy (fi kitabihi Tahsil nazoir al-Qurʼon)”. Majallat Kulliyat at-tarbiya li-l-banat. Vol. 2019. Iss.10. Article 23 (in Arabic).
18. Husayn, Muhammad (2005). At-Tanzir al-maqosidiy inda-l-Imam Muhammad Tohur ibn Oshur. Al-Jazoir: Jamiat Jazoir (in Arabic).
19. Imom, Kamoliddin Muhammad (2015). Al-maqosid qobla-sh-Shotibiy // ar-Robita al-Muhammadiyya. Rabot: https://www.arrabita (in Arabic).
20. Jug‘aym, Nuʼmon (2013). Turuq kashf an maqosid ash-Shoriʼ. Ammon: Dar an-nafais (in Arabic).
21. Juyushiy, M. (1981). Al-Hakim at-Termiziy: dirosa li osorihi va afkorihi. Qohira: Dar an-Nahda al-arabiyya (in Arabic).
22. Muhammad Sodiq, M.Y. (2019). Usulul fiqh. Toshkent: Hilol-nashr (in Uzbek).
23. Nasr, Somi (1981). Hakim Termiziyning “Ilm al-avliyo” asari kirish qismi. Qohira: al-Maktaba al-hurriya al-hadisa (in Arabic).
24. Risuniy, Ahmad (2014). Muhodorot fi maqosid ash-sharia. Qohira: Dor al-kalima (in Arabic).
25. Samak, Muhammad Ali (2007). Abu Bakr Qaffol Shoshiy. “Mahosin ash-sharia” asari nashrining kirish qismi. Bayrut: Dor al-kutub al-ilmiyya (in Arabic).
26. Shimmel, Annemari (2012). Mir islamskogo mistitsizma / Perevod s angl. N.Prigarinoy. Moskva: Sadra (in Russian).
27. Shoshiy, Nizomuddin (2016). Usulush Shoshiy / A.Ahmadaliyev nashrga tayyorlagan. Toshkent: Movarounnahr (in Uzbek).
28. Heer, Nicholas (1960). Al-Ḥakīm al-Tirmidhī’s Kitāb Ithbāt al-‘Ilal. A paper read at the 1960 annual meeting of the American Oriental Society held in New Haven, Connecticut (in English).
29. Subkiy, Tojuddin (1999). Tabaqot ash-shofiiyya al-kubro / Mustafo Ahmad Ato nashrga tayyorlagan. Bayrut: Dor al-kutub al-ilmiyya, 1999. V. I. (in Arabic).
30. Suyutiy, Abdurahmon (1936). Tabaqot al-mufassirin. Qohira: Maktaba vahba. V.1. (in Arabic).
31. Sviri, Sara (2002). “Words of power and the power of words”. Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam.Vol. 2002: Iss 27. Article 13 (in English).
32. Zahriy, X. (2003). Taʼlil ash-sharia bayna-s-sunna va-sh-shia. Bayrut: Dar al-hadiy (in Arabic).
33. Zahriy, X. (2009). Tajalliyot al-Burhon. Bayrut: al-Maktaba al-Asriyya. (in Arabic).
34. Zahriy, X. (2013). Hakim Khuroson va anis az-zamon. Rabot: Markaz ad-dirosot va-l-abhos (in Arabic).

